Who Is A Better Investor – Carl Icahn or Warren Buffett?

Time is calling Carl Icahn one of the most influential investors of our time and deservedly so. Icahn’s recent performance in Netflix, Herbalife and Apple among many others has been nothing short of impressive. Josh Brown has a good overview of why Carl Icahn is different, but how does he fare against another investment legend – Warren Buffett? How does he fare against the market? Let the chart do the talking.

Below I am comparing the performance of Icahn Enterprises (the chart with the candle sticks) with Berkshire Hathaway (bright orange) and the S & P 500:

Screen Shot 2013-12-05 at 8.11.39 AM

Big Returns Need Big Corrections

In October 2008, Warren Buffett wrote an op-ed in New York Times titled “Buy American. I Am”. When volatility and correlations were at record high levels, when most investors were running scared and could not sell their stocks fast enough, Buffett was buying with both hands.

Five years later, the S & P 500 has more than doubled. More interestingly, there are 115 stocks that have gone up more than 1000% in the same time. The big winners come from various industries: biotech, media, furniture stores, a Chinese search engine, an yoga apparel store, an online travel agency, pizza restaurants, regional banks, casinos, hotels and many others. Many of them were priced for bankruptcy, which never materialized. You did not have to guess which ones were going go survive. You could have made a ton of money by entering in the middle of their trends, when their existence was not questionable and when they were making new 52-week highs every month.

Every time I mention the best performing stocks over a certain period of time, there is always someone to criticize me – “Don’t tell me what happened. Tell me what will happen next. Tell me the next stocks that will go up over 1000% in the next 5 years”.

I don’t have a crystal ball. I don’t know. No one does.

What I know is that big corrections put the foundations for big future moves. Bear markets make investors a lot of money. Most of them just don’t know it at the time.

What I know is that many of the best future performers are likely to make new 52-week highs well ahead of the market averages.

What I know is that strong stocks leave traces, so you could participate in part of their trends. Take the best performing stock of the past 5 years for example. Pharmacyclics ($PCYC) went up more than 110 times in the last half decade. It more than doubled in each of the past three years. It hit new all-time highs multiple times. You did not need a time machine to notice this trend, but you needed some basic trend following rules in order to stay with this trend long enough to make a difference in your returns.

Where Is The Froth?

This morning, I saw someone tweeting an interesting observation by legendary investor Peter Lynch:

“Far more money has been lost by investors preparing for corrections or trying to anticipate corrections than in corrections themselves”.

It is a really good reference to many investors’ natural bias to constantly look for some form of mean-reversion in the midst of strong trends. Blind contrarians are a good thing for trends. Every trend needs doubters and skeptics – otherwise there won’t be anyone left to buy.

The last quarter of each positive year is often marked  by performance chasing by under-invested money managers. So far in Q4, most of the momentum leaders from the first 3 quarters have not only not outperformed, but have experienced sizable corrections. The best performers since October have been breakouts from several months long ranges. I don’t know about you, but I cannot call this a froth. The market has been very level-headed and it has constantly corrected through sector rotations and pullbacks to major moving averages. The fear of missing out has not been that much bigger than the fear of losing.

It is true that at this particular time, the indexes are a bit technically extended and overbought. It won’t be a surprise to see some form of consolidation through time (sideways) or space (price decline) in the near-term perspective. It might have already started on Friday afternoon – nothing to fret about. It is still a bull market of stocks, where dips are likely to be welcomed as buying opportunities.

logo_dark